Forced To Leave My Job (resign)
What is constructive dismissal?
Forced to leave my job, is defined under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW ACT), as a constructive dismissal. The term dismissed is defined where a person’s employment has been terminated at the employer’s initiative. Or a person was forced to resign because of the conduct or course of conduct engaged in by the employer.
A forced resignation, also referred to as constructive termination or dismissal, is when an employee has no real choice but to resign. This means the onus is on the employee to prove that their resignation was not voluntary and that they were forced to leave. This issue may form the basis of a jurisdictional issue when dealing with claims such as Unfair Dismissal applications in the Fair Work Commission.
Have you been forced to leave?
In establishing whether an employee has been “forced to leave my job”. The employee must demonstrate that the employer has taken action with the intent to bring the relationship to an end. Or that has that probable result. In the words of the full bench in O’Meara v Stanley Works Pty Ltd, adopted in Bupa Aged Care Australia Pty Ltd v Tavassoli., The test is whether the employer engaged in conduct with the intention of bringing the employment to an end. Or whether termination of the employment was the probable result of the employer’s conduct such that the employee had no effective or real choice but to leave.
Similarly, the Australian case of Mohazb v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (No 2). States that “An important feature is that the act of the employer results directly or consequentially in the termination of the employment and the employment relationship is not voluntarily left by the employee”. That is, had the employer not taken the action it did, the employee would have remained in the employment relationship”. For example, an employee leaving after having been paid under half of what he was owed in wages over a period of 4 months.
Termination by the employer as their conduct forced the employee to leave.
This was held to be a termination by the employer as their conduct forced the employee to leave. Similarly, if an employee is complaining about something within their right. Such as sexual harassment they are suffering, and the Company continually fails to take action, the employee may feel forced to leave as they can no longer bear to work.
If an employee feels forced to leave in the heat of the moment or under extreme pressure. Then special circumstances may arise.
What can I do if I feel I have been forced out of employment?
In order to qualify for unfair dismissal, the employee must have completed at least the minimum employment period with the employer. The minimum employment period is 6 months continuous service at a particular time, for non-small business employers. If the employer is a small business, which employs less than 15 employees at the relevant time, the employee must have completed at least 12 months of continuous service at the particular time.
A general protections claim can be made if the employee feels forced to leave after they have exercised a workplace right and made a complaint in regards to their employment and because of this complaint, the employer has acted adversely towards the employee by engaging in conduct that has forced the employee to leave. An Unfair Dismissal application or a General Protections Application must be lodged with the Commission within 21 days of the termination taking effect.
Unfair Dismissal and Being Forced to Leave
If an employee is forced to leave, the employer may object to this unfair dismissal application on the basis that the employee effectively resigned. Thus there is a jurisdictional issue. If the employer objects on the basis of a jurisdictional issue, a jurisdictional hearing can occur before or after conciliation. A jurisdictional hearing is a formal process by which a member of the Commission will make a decision as to whether the Commission can deal with the unfair dismissal case.
This process involves the parties to the matter making submissions, giving sworn evidence, and provides an opportunity to challenge or cross-examine the other party’s evidence. The jurisdictional hearing will assess whether the employee has been forced to leave or resign and thus they have been constructively terminated, in order to qualify for an unfair dismissal application.
Forced resignation applies
Sexual harassment
Obvious demotion
Unreasonably relocated
Significant reduction in pay and bonus structure.
Bullied and harassment, causing health risk
OH&s breaches, physical well being is at risk
The list is brief, its to give you an idea of what is considered constructive dismissal. Give us a call to discus your circumstances. Never resign until you have got advice.
Signs your on the way out
Your Employer is turning into a micromanager
You’re used to being left alone to do your work and have enjoyed the supportive feedback of your employer for as long as you can remember. Suddenly, your employer begins nitpicking all your work and doling out frustratingly vague criticisms. Bad sign. Your employer may have lost confidence in you or is looking for justifications for letting you go.
If your employer’s micromanaging is accompanied by constructive recommendations or specific feedback, they more than likely want you to improve. However, if the criticism is nonspecific, excessive or focused on issues that have little importance, they may be more interested in seeing you leave. The employer is starting to put the pressure on to see you out of there. They (the employer) say it’s for you to lift your game and their there to help you. You will know by their attutude, the unreasonableness of what’s focused on if they want to get rid of you.
Your company now wants to document everything
Feedback on your work used to be informal and undocumented. Any mistakes you made were pointed out to you in private, with a friendly talk. Now everything suddenly involves paperwork. You’re being asked to fill out time sheets so the company can keep track of how you spend your hours and minutes. Feedback that used to transpire over a coffee break now requires an email chain, with your boss’s boss cc’d. All of a sudden there is survallence cameras installed to watch you.
Most employers have some sort of progressive discipline process that, when used properly, gives an underperforming employee the opportunity to improve. However, if the employer wants you gone and implements this with little advance notice, it may be an attempt to psych you out. Or “a form of intimidation to make you feel insecure or stressed enough to start looking for a new job,”
You’re not being groomed for the future
Your professional development is essential to your value as an employee. So if your company has pulled back on growth opportunities for you, they likely don’t see you as being around long term.
When you’re not getting new projects assigned to you, it’s a sign the boss isn’t interested in your future with the company,” Similarly, if you see others in your office receiving more professional development, it may be time to reassess your career path. Timing in life can be everything, when is it time to move on or not. don’t make it a battle of wills. This is all about you and your family. Not what the employer gets away with or not.
You’re getting the silent treatment
Communication and tranparency is vital in every organisation. Your presence at meetings, on calls and at events, as well as on email, group chat correspondence, gives you access to this constant flow of information. When you’re abruptly cut off or pushed out of the circle, take note—especially if other co-workers remain in the loop.
Maybe this means your employer leaves you out of key client meetings, keeps rescheduling your weekly lunch date or oddly skips the hallway hellos. Perhaps the frostiness is coming from your peers too, making the water cooler feel more like a popsicle stand. That could indicate that those colleagues have picked up on your status as persona non grata, and don’t want to become tainted by association. Everybody acts as if you have leprosy and “runs for the hills”.
Your Employer is taking your work away
A company is like one big team, so if you’re used to being a starting player and then all of a sudden you get benched in favor of other players, you’re right to feel suspicious. Your clearly not part of the gang anymore.
Whenever a employer starts giving away tasks that you always do. Or that they know you enjoy—without some type of explanation, they’re communicating that they either don’t value you or don’t trust you to do it anymore. The same goes if they’re giving you grunt work that’s not normally your job. This has all the signs of heading for a redundancy.
Compensation and remedies
For an unfair dismissal claim, compensation may be awarded to an employee if the Fair Work Commission is satisfied that reinstatement is inappropriate. Compensation in this form is designed to compensate unfairly terminated employees in lieu of reinstatement for losses reasonably attributable to the unfair termination. As a result, compensation cannot be awarded for shock, distress, or humiliation.
When determining the amount of compensation that may be awarded
For a general protection claim, the Fair Work Commission may order the employee to be reinstated. Make orders relating to continuity or lost remuneration and compensation. In regards to compensation, this can include non-economic loss such as hurt, humiliation, and distress. This is where there is a causal connection between the contravention and the loss. Compensation in this form is referred to as general damages.
Forced To Leave My Job (resign)
We are not employment lawyers, but leading workplace representatives, commentator’s and advisors, want advice?. Get it from us, its free, prompt and honest, we are here for you. Any Fair work Australia and Fair work Commission matters, including unfair dismissals, workplace investigations, redundancies. Workers rights, probation issues, whatever give us a call 1800 333 666.
We are proud of our staff and the outcomes we achieve for our clients.
We work in all states. Victoria, NSW, QLD, SA, WA, Tas, NT
Articles similar to Forced To Leave My Job (resign)
Resignation letter do’s and dont’s
Are constructive claims too hard to win?
